Confused as to why Amazon didn’t strike through a negative feedback and won’t remove it?

[mod edit: removed category template instructions]

We received a neg today from a buyer who says he hadn’t received the item yet and that he would have to file a claim if it’s not received by next week.

Shipping label was bought through Amazon (claims protected), shipped on time, carrier scan received on time. Looks like it went out for delivery to the buyer last week (3 days before the EDD) and then it was marked as “return to sender”. It doesn’t say why….which is unusual. I googled the address and my guess is the buyer’s address they put was incomplete as it seems it’s an apartment complex but there was no mention of any apartment number on the address when they paid.

I then requested it be removed and they denied it saying “The tracking information provided does not match the order, and we cannot verify if delivery occurred within the estimated timeframe.”

No clue was this even means? What do they mean it doesn’t match the order? The tracking on the order is obviously the one we purchased from Amazon and the buyer’s city on the USPS scan matches their city on the order.

Wondering if Amazon sold you a recycled label before it should have been recycled thus showing a previous address to Amazon from past usage?

I would be tempted to appeal and tie this together for them with a screenshot of the order page with the tracking number, and another screenshot of the USPS tracking page that shows it out for delivery and return to sender. If they look at attachments on cases anymore?
It sounds like it was a bot reply?

My instinct is to wait for the returned package and photograph it and the label with the proper address.

Usually the stick they ‘return to sender’ label over the original address, but sometimes they can be peeled off carefully to show it. I suggest 2 photos in that case, one before peeling it off and one after.

They finally removed it on the third appeal back. It’s evident I finally got a rep with a brain. :slight_smile:

Trust me, I laid it out for them very clearly the first time, haha.

The game now is called “beat the bots”

You got lucky and good!

There was a point that you got two chances to get a feedback removed then there was a threat of “dont ask again or else”

Sometimes if denied it is best to let the case sit for 24-48 hrs then appeal. Also in your case “removal” should have been denied as “strike through” is i believe the correct action. Sometimes a request for removal confuses ss/bots

:waving_hand: :waving_hand: :waving_hand:

I hope I did not offend, I can’t always keep track of every poster’s level of expertise; and posted advice may help someone else reading here too.

Of course not, don’t be silly!

It’s sad you have to basically write messages like you are taking to a 5 year old when communicating with Amazon.

I didn’t open new cases. I stayed on the same case number. You normally get automatic bots the first 2 times on denial (meaning you get replies back within a minute or two). I feel it’s not until the 3rd time where you actually get a person.

Opening a new case to look at the same feedback is definitely a no no.