Identifying Macro Economic Factors

Does anyone have anything more scientific than looking to see if other sellers are complaining about low sales - in order to determine if there is in fact economic pressure affecting e-commerce sales of discretionary items?

It seems at any given time you can easily find a seller complaining sales are off.

I’m looking to build a list of links, reports, data sources that can help shed light onto if people are spending more or less online.

Meanwhile I will be optimizing the heck out of all of my listings to make sure I’m not the cause of any potential dip in sales.

Please share what sources you use to get get an idea of what US shoppers are actually doing. Thank you!

There is a YouTube channel I follow (link below) that reports on consumer-focused economic factors such as credit card defaults (up), savings depletion (up), car repos (up), McDonald’s pricing (down to drive sales) and sales (down despite lower pricing), soda pricing and sales (same as McDs), and other factors that identify customer demand. He can be a bit doom and gloom but, as the kids say, he brings the receipts. I follow others, as well, that track China’s economy and such. Personal experience is that the wealthy are still spending on discretionary items but the mid to low incomes aren’t.

I like this question, I believe the answer can be as short or as long as you want. And please, don’t take any of the comments that I make the wrong way, the are not intended in bad faith.

My question is, does macro-economic really affect your product? And of course, the answer is “everything is affected by macro-econ.” But the question is catered more to “do you sell fidget spinners or GPU microchips for datacenters?” (IDK if that’s even a thing). Obviously different items are affected at different rates. The fidget spinners don’t even qualify as a vanity item, and are a fade that can wane at any second. The “GPU microchips” (again, don’t know if that’s how they are called) are significantly more affected by Washington, Beijing or EU (well, not really EU)

I would imagine that for 99% of the items sold on Amazon macroeconomics pay less than we could intuitively assume. Not that I diminish any of the things that the much esteemed SellerFeller indicated above (inflation, debt, repos, etc.) Those are extremely real concerns that affect spending, but because of the nature of the items that are sold on Amazon, I believe that under stressful, yet normal macroecon circumstances, can be managed. For the purpose of your question, and with the exception of very specific items (that probably should not be sold on Amazon), I believe that Amazon items can be divided in two categories: the things that people need, and the things that people want. The things that people need are somewhat protected from the intraday ebbs and flows (though still subjected to competition, price, availability, etc), while the things that people want are completely depended of the extra cash that macroecon may leave in the table.

Now, in the US between 25-50% of Amazon shoppers have an income of at least $80k. That means that aprox 40% of Amazon’s buyers have a decent level of spending cash, AKA disposable income, AKA can indulge in purchasing wants that are affected by macroecon. That immediately should give a (rough) floor to anybody selling “want” items of what percentage of the sales should remain save from the whims of DC during normal circumstances.

Of course, that means that the remaining 60% of the sales of said “want” items are more vulnerable to “hey, I ran out of money”. Funny enough, and this is consumer behavior, “want items” are often more popular among the 60% that is affected by the tightening of belts, because of aspirational status (“I can’t buy a Tesla Roasdter, but I can buy $200 shoes and the new iPhone”) and, again, funny enough, during a financial squeeze it’s not uncommon for aspirational items to become more of a need than a want (while remaining an absolute want and not a need).

IMO, I believe that the most important indicator to study for the impact of macroecon for an established Amazon seller account that sells either wants or needs, is the contrast between current month and same month during previous years. That’s the indicator that will show if the item(s) is going down whether due to price, vouge, competition, or any other factor.

One last thought, there’s an old saying “sell tissues when everybody is crying”. And there are millions of variations to said saying, “sell shovels when people search for gold”, “sell computer space when people mine for bitcoin” (ok, nobody says that) but what I mean is that even during crashes (which we aren’t in one, just in a very bad inflationary spiral) there are opportunities. So even if an item is being squeezed, either by macro factors, or just because it’s time has come and gone, there are always going to be things immune, or even nurtured, by the current environment

My products are customizable, and discretionary - they are not a necessity so if someone is in a cash crunch, they might decide against purchasing. Or, they may look at our product as a less-expensive way of upgrading vehicle or decorating their home or office space. So I believe there is an angle both for and against macro forces helping or hurting my sales.

I think this just drives me to consider marketing towards existing friction points and to overcome doubt or hesitation. I can do this by promoting value and offering short-term coupons to get more people to close the sale.

At the same time I have customers in the $175,000+ income bracket that are not necessarily spending less now, so I have to continue to convey quality to them (and others).

My sessions have remained steady, but conversion rates have dropped - so it appears people are still window shopping and wanting to buy, but fewer are making the purchase than 3+ months ago.

Two things I would consider,

  1. I wouldn’t change anything drastic until after the elections. For one reason or another, everything gets a bit slower before elections. More so when is the “most important election of our lifetime” for the 9th consecutive time.
  2. Consider the seasonality of buyer behavior. I know that my sales will drop as soon as the pumpkins are forgotten and replaced with turkeys.

I’d suggest never to compromise the image or the quality of your product.
If you want to offer a lower cost version, that’s a different product, preferably under a different brand. Think cars, i.e Toyota-Lexus, Fiat-Ferrari (not-no-mo, but for 60 years Fiat owned Ferrari)

Hi @Setalpz , here are some places to start, perhaps.

I did not quote the data here–you’ll have to go to the posts and/or their sources directly–but I did add a snippet or two so that you can decide which ones might work best for your purposes.

I tried to stick with October and current information.

And this piece has a lovely data summary:


From https://www.marketplace.org/story/2026/10/16/consumers-pull-back-on-some-discretionary-spending:

If you dig into the retail sales data from September, you’ll find there are particular areas where consumers are pulling back. While gas stations saw their sales go up a lot, thanks in large part to higher gas prices, some discretionary categories took a hit. For example, spending at sporting goods, hobby, musical instrument, and book stores was down 0.5% from the month before after rising pretty steadily most of the year.


From the government, October’s Beige Book: The Fed - Monetary Policy: Beige Book (Branch)

Over half of the Districts noted that consumer spending was driven by high-income households. Even in Dallas, where District firms reported solid retail sales, there were “some reports of lower-income customers being more cautious with spending.”


From https://www.circana.com/post/circana-s-2026-holiday-study-finds-consumers-spending-selectively-not-stepping-away

“Consumers are becoming far more purposeful about discretionary spending, which means successful brands will need to move beyond competing on price alone,” adds Barrett. “While economic pressures are creating a more selective shopper, they are not eliminating demand. The opportunity this holiday season lies in connecting with consumers where inspiration and discovery are happening, from social platforms to AI assistants, while delivering the value, relevance, and confidence shoppers need to justify their purchases.”


From https://www.retaildive.com/news/holiday-season-retail-spending-sales-decline-outlook/832624/

Higher prices across the board are changing some spending patterns. About 77% of consumers say inflation has changed their shopping behaviors, per the Simon-Kucher data.

“While overall outlook is positive, we do expect that the experience of individual households will vary significantly based on income levels and wealth, and exposure to higher everyday costs like gasoline and other household essentials,” NRF’s Chief Economist and Executive Director of Research Mark Mathews said on a media call about the forecast Thursday. “As we head into the holiday period, if gas prices remain higher, we do expect that this will have a larger impact on households at the lower end of the income spectrum. Now, despite inflationary pressure, we expect goods prices to run lower than headline inflation as retailers respond to a price-conscious consumer.”


From https://cressetcapital.com/articles/market-update/market-update-10-6-26-the-consumer-squeeze/

Aggregate spending will hold up longer than the anecdotes suggest. That’s because the top quintile of earners accounts for nearly half of consumer spending, and those households are cushioned by asset values, particularly equities and housing. That is why retail sales and aggregate spending still look healthy even as payroll growth stalls. A K-shaped economy can keep growing while half its consumers retrench.

American households are making hard choices and cutting back. They are eating instead of playing and filling half a tank instead of a whole one. Affluent consumers are carrying the aggregate, which can continue for a while. But the middle is running on savings and installment credit, paying more for energy, and facing a hiring market that has nearly stalled.

A caveat to all: Remember that higher dollar figures do not necessarily reflect a successful holiday season for retailers. The spending total will likely increase, but:

  1. that overall increase does not equal more profit or less inventory for retailers,
  2. some discretionary categories and product types will not see item-level sales increases YOY (and will likely sell fewer products), and
  3. actual sales for every retailer will depend on the SES of its typical holiday shopper (because middle- and lower-income buyers are cutting back from 2025, while higher-income buyers continue to purchase but at 2026’s higher prices, and thus masking some bigger economic problems for now).

Absolutely. A two-prong strategy would target both the higher-income shoppers willing to pay a reasonable increase from 2025 for (hopefully) the same quality, and lower- and middle-income shoppers who want good value as they look at strategic spending.

And both prongs would entice the middle-income shoppers relying on credit cards and BNPL this 2026 holiday season.

Absolutely, but I watch things like inflation, cost of basic needs, and the true unemployment number (not the one that doesn’t include people out of unemployment benefits or who gave up looking).

For example, the price of gas going up is going to lower or eliminate frivolous spending. I remember 2008 and when people had to empty their paychecks into their tanks, the restaurants suffered and businesses closed. So focusing on affordability, value, and need are the things that will keep a business thriving during economic downturns.

I recently added a new brand that has a lower price point for the same product categories we already carry, one that didn’t test well a year ago, and are selling like hot cakes now. I had a feeling it was going to do well since people aren’t going to have the money for the more elite brand (like buying Nike vs Reebok) and appreciate the affordability. In 2008/2009, the $1 store hit record profits.

Actually, the number of competitive products available and their individual attractiveness, makes this a segment which is probably not any different from other market segments. There may be enough vendors of manufacturing services who can make these chips as there are for potato chips. Obviously, better capitalized.

If feel accosted by analysis of macro economic factors, and believe that they might be irrelevant to reality much of the time.

Different economists, with different biases emphasize different macro economic specifics, often emphasizing those which suit their current biases,

The FED has, over the years, changed its preferred metrics for factors like inflation, with no certainty that they have improved its accuracy in choosing an appropriate course of action. You can choose almost any other group of economists and find a similar lack of consistency.

My business sucks this month. Is it the economy? Is it nationwide psychological depression? Is it Tik Tok? Does it matter why? The only thing I know is, at this time, few people want and can afford much of what I am offering.

Am I depressed by the state of my business? Not really, I have plenty of other sources of depression, and my personal economic condition has not deteriorated by much.

I have noted that the public opinion polls I participate in are searching for the right economic issue to change how people vote, and they are getting more desperate for an answer.

Well, IDK. On a day like today when the stock market decided to check how hard it could go down in one session, it does feel like if you’re building “GPU microchips” or any other datacenter nonsense (that may be useful, but to the average person it isn’t), the macroeconomic factors caught up with you.

But that was mostly my point. Macroeconomic factors are whether we will build 5000 new plants that will create 250k jobs, and will allow for more people to buy stuff. That takes years to move and years for its inertia to slow down.

Day to day, even month to month sales are more affected by weather disruptions (hurricanes or snowstorms) than by macroeconomics themselves. That’s why my suggestion remains, check the same period a year ago, and there you can decide if a macroeconomic factor is involved.

As of 3:15 PM today.

Dow is down .17%
Nasdaq down 2.76%
S&P down 1.4%

Are these amounts signal or noise? They look like noise to me.

What tests of statistical significance do they pass?

Is this evidence of a trend or the fact that traders have to trade and will whether they have a reason or not?

My own bias is that the market is significantly overvalued. And is totally resistant to correcting its valuation. But that has been my position for multiple presidential administrations, and the market is higher today than it was when I reached that conclusion.

It is not clear to me that if we created 250k new jobs, we could fill the positions.

My comment was more a joke than fearmongering for a market correction.
Elections are coming, the market will be manipulated and misbehave. Somebody will make a lot of money.

The market has been forced to play a game where it takes care of itself and can not correct.
Everybody is told to add to the 401k, the IRA, the roth, the 529, the HSA, pension fund, brokerage, etc.
When millions are being “forced” to invest in account were there’s a penalization for using the money, you have created a positive cash intake with accumulation (mind you, I’m very pro these vehicles)

I do believe however that under these circumstances inflation is inevitable. The market goes up, you had $100 that suddenly become $150, created money out of nowhere (printed might be the word), outcome is inflation.

Filling positions is easy. Making them create value, that’s the trick

I like NPR’s Marketplace for tracking consumer sentiment, but I’m not narrow-focused on what it means for my bottom line. They cover Fed reports, etc. Spending overall vs durable goods.

https://www.marketplace.org

Is yesterday’s drop in treasury bond yields a macro economic factor.

It was one of the 10 greatest drops in the past decade or more.

The desire for investment in bonds surged as money flowed out of stocks.

Any of the Macro Economic Factors could simply be a side effect of the blurring of the lines between investing and gambling.

Why are the markets and indicators and everything so messed up as compared to decades ago?

“Everyone” is now in all markets at all times:

“Everyone” has a 401k, 403b, IRA, Roth IRA, 529 kid’s education plan, municipalities’ pensions, etc.

They aren’t individually trading, but someone is on their behalf, and potentially it is an automated system that follows certain rules and that much money acting “uniformly” could cause havoc.

More money goes in every day than comes out… for now.

As boomers live longer and GenX begins to retire the flow will eventually flip.

All of it is basically a ponzi scheme: “Everyone” expects to get more out than they put in. That is impossible.

It can go on a very long time and has.

Anyone trained in investments in the 1980s looks upon the current P/E ratios for stocks as unrealistic. Most who were involved then will not live long enough for Amazon’s earnings to exceed the price they have to pay to buy the stock today.

Individual stocks more often move with their market segment, as consumer stocks are today. The reason, the cheap ETFs and what they hold.

Speculative funds based on derivatives, have cost us at least one recession and will probably trigger some more.

Those of us who invest with a buy and hold strategy, are at a particular disadvantage. I finally threw in the towel and place the bulk of my investments in the hands of a professional manager. It is extremely disconcerting to see my investments not in stocks but in a large number of sector and index funds which overlap in their coverage.

Today was the monthly rebalancing and the number of transactions, buy and sell, was as always overwhelming.

90% of my investments are worth more than I paid for them, and most of the 10% which are not are carryovers from when I picked stocks, I do not currently need to harvest the losses, so they remain and generate a little cash from dividends.

The casinos have always done better in bad times than a rational person might expect, and there is no reason while the stock market should do worse.

That assumes no more than the current political upheaval, I think.

That’s social security, not the stock market
Too many ways to affect it. While retirement funds are a massive part of the stock market, they are not the whole of it.
The biggest incentive that retirees have to not deplete their retirement funds is precisely that they can continue to grow, it becomes a self fulfilling prophecy. You don’t empty it (also because big brother… but different story) because you want to ensure that it lasts till the end, and expect compounding to keep it at an even value. Any share that is not being traded is effectively off the market, and inherently increases the value of the company, fund, etf, whatever.

Lastly, there are too many “tools” that can manipulate the market. From printing more money so that it finds its way back, to allowing if needed for foreign investment, or simply creating jobs, regarding of how value adding they are, just to keep the wheel running (what is corporate or government if not just an excuse for cashflow?) that’s not going to stop. It sadly is many things but not free market. It is too big to fail, and I’m personally against that, but just because I’m against it doesn’t mean I can’t benefit from its own contradictions.

The Amsterdam stock exchange has operated since 1602 (funny enough, it wasn’t affected by the Tulip Craze, it was too different from today’s stock exchange. No IPO for Tulips :joy:)

Absolutely, because as Lake said:

This made me chuckle. A stock at 30xs is seen today as “undervalued”. When I started investing my dad told me that anything above 5x was too risky. I certainly abide by that lesson. At least for a decent part of my assets.

For this I’m very happy for you. At the end of the day, that was the point of investing. I honestly hope that is not just growth for the sake of growth, but that it has and still provides freedom and opportunities to do what you want.