When you get a scam return

LOL

I had heard that Safe T Claims depend on Amazon issuing the refund, but things change so often that I can’t keep up with it. I’ll keep the link for the reimbursement policy open in case I need it, though.

Thank you for taking the time to help, Dogtamer!

2 Likes

Exactly what I’m trying to decide, Prime!

The restocking fee goes up in increments of 20% from 0% to 100%, so it looks like if I refund anything at all, then I’ll at least lose 20% of the sale.

I know, on a $37 pair of earrings I’ve already spent far more time than the earrings are worth, but this customer’s behavior needs to get some negative attention from Amazon, and I’m hoping that I can help get them that negative attention.

5 Likes

I’ve been hoping to see more sellers with more experience offer advice here. Maybe tonight will be more active.

I agree that we need to push back against these abusive buyers for any chance they get weeded out.

3 Likes

In my understanding, Safe-t claims are to right a wrong where Amazon refunds either a RFS return or a SFP return. If in fact the Handmade category is ever able to file a safe-t claim, you will be able to find out with the eligibility tool. My guess is support is in error telling you that you will be able file a claim after Amazon refunds buyer. If you refund, the max you will be able to refund is 50%. Personally I would direct the buyer to file an A-Z as they did not return the correct item and you have all the message as well as photo evidence to support your defense to the claim. I certainly may be wrong but support has never outright refunded a Handmade order for me, but rather filed an A-Z order on behalf of the buyer, which I then successfully defended with documentation and messages.

4 Likes

Sounds good, Wade, thank you! I already messaged the buyer to tell them that they needed to return the proper item for a refund. Would you just go ahead and tell the buyer that they can also file an A to Z claim, or just wait to see what they do? The 48 hours started at 9 am this morning.

I found a place where you can mark the item as materially different and charge a 100% restocking fee. So I don’t know if that counts as a refund at all, but there is a place to upload pictures of the return and give 500 characters of information. Maybe I should just do that instead?

2 Likes

That’s what I was going to recommend, but like Prime I wanted to see if Wade or other Handmade Artisans would weigh in.

3 Likes

I did not realize this was available so I agree with @Dogtamer to go this route. If an A-z is then filed you still have all the further documentation to defend/appeal.

3 Likes

Thank you, I’ll try this and see what happens.

4 Likes

It says “Upload Complete”. I’ll let you know what happens. Thank you to all of you who helped me with this!

9 Likes

Just wanted to update you to say that the buyer has not continued to press this case, as primetime predicted. Hopefully they’re gone for good!

11 Likes