Let’s see how our reply flies …
Reply on NSFE:
Google: Can a amazon seller file a SAFE-T claim on a returned FBA order?
Apparently, it has yet to make any impression:
Admittedly, in one of the execrable “nested” replies, the OP mentions that one of the 4 Order IDs from this scumbag filmmaker was FBM/MFN - apparently, the latest one, after OP removed the FBA Offer-Listing - but the
most-recent of his/her ‘stand-alone’ replies, made 042426, clearly shows the 3 FBA Orders, and it’s not the only reply that mentions that status.
Poor ol’ Xander just can’t seem to wrap his/her/its noggin’ round the simple truth that FBA ≠ FBM.
He used to be alright. I’m wondering if that account has a new owner/operator. Because (sigh) this is something “Xander” used to be able to grasp.
I would second that without reservation.
In Q2 & Q3 of 2025, when the infamous “Pokemon Notebook/Balloon/Bubble Wand/Dollar Store Goods/novelty item Returns” scam was in full flower, Xander took the point on passing along information to the CCU (‘Amazonese’ for “Counterfeit Crimes Unit”); the simple fact that the uproarious furor over being subject to that particular “brushing” technique subsequently died out nearly completely would seem to suggest that his/her efforts were not in vain.
Count me among those who wouldn’t deny that that’s certainly a possibility, as Amazon has quite demonstrably been playin’ fast & loose with such tag-teaming, at the very least,* since this 061319 OSFE post (link, NSFE URL) and this 062619 OSFE thread (link, NSFE URL) - both cases where the former AHT SME Arthur_Amazon made a reply signed as “Bryson” (and in the latter case went back on 071219 & modified the original signature, after you yourself, among others of the forum vets, highlighted the discrepancy both there and elsewhere) - we’ve seen clear evidence of such
behaviour.
There is certainly credible evidence that this phenomenon has continued, intermittently, down to the present day; recent examples of which include the near-invariably helpful Sandy_Amazon’s ‘Serina signature Snafu’ (link, SAS) - amended 4 days later as a ‘typo’ (link, SAS) - and perhaps also by the seemingly-inexplicable shift in handles undertaken in Q1 2026 by Ammy/Amyy_Amazon (link, SAS).
Still, and not just because Xander was among the first members of the FMT-CMT I myself noticed supplying a ‘Cyrano-generated’ URL direction (link, SAS) to this or that of Amazon’s web resources - not to mention the sheer plentitude of examples to be found in more-recent posts by members of s/he/its cohort, of which I would likewise assert ARE (rather obviously, methinks, to even the fabled “Most-Casual of Observers”) most-likely to be attributable to Project Rainier-spawned GenAI/LLM deployments - it doesn’t currently appear to me that there’s much reason to suspect that Occam’s presumed take might not wind up hanging the hat of this matter upon that peg alone, no matter which Amazonian is actually operating this and that NSFE Posting Profile at any given hour of any given day.
*
There are earlier-posted examples of the same type of thing still-extant in my archives, but while I was cooling my heels waiting for Legal to sign off on my desire to join SAS, I found time to conduct some verifications that those examples were still visible in the NSFE, often enough with no success..
I miss Susan. She knew how to read.
Agreed.
AND how to get things done, @ least when Amazon would allow her the opportunity to do so…