While it is a good concept, I just don’t trust them. We have similar products, that get abused and we package everything so it is clear don’t restock this. Works most the time.
The problem I see, I don’t trust Amazon with this task. I know our “destroyed” items will end up sold on a skid to some auction house or flea market.
I can not afford to have our brands (and our handmade artisan products) that are damaged back in the world of commerce.
We are happy paying the return fee, salvaging what we can, recycling what we can. The rest, we cut up in little parts, our local trash company uses the waste to generate electricity.